May 28, 2019
Memorial Day has come and gone. I’ve read the stories of soldiers who fought and died for freedom, watched the parades, and listened to the commentators praise our military service members. I’ve stood facing the flag with my hand over my heart five days a week and said the Pledge of Allegiance in front of a room full of immigrants and recited the words, “with Liberty and Justice for all.” But I’m not feeling it this year. I understand that my perspective may be in the minority and it might make me unpopular; I’ll say it anyway. I’m a little bit angry about all the praise for war.
Don’t get me wrong. My father, my mother, and my uncles fought in World War II. My cousin served in the Marine Corps during the Vietnam War. His name is engraved on the Wall on the National Mall in Washington, DC. I’ve taken my students there and pointed out Peter M. Sullivan on Panel 15E, Line 10. They were impressed when the docent climbed a ladder to create a rubbing for me. It made the experience a little more real for them. My students from Vietnam were silent. Even though we’d read an excerpt from Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried, later they told me, “Miss, I thought we were going to see something about my culture!” They understood that the Vietnam Veterans Memorial was not about them. They helped me see it in a new light.
I have cousins in the Army today, and I’m sure they are making a sacrifice to serve in the military. I am not against giving people respect for the jobs they do. But why aren’t we giving the same respect to people actively promoting peace? to students who lose their lives to gun violence in schools? According to Education Week , and the Washington Post more American students died from mass shootings than died during active-duty combat while serving their country in the U.S. military. There have been 13 school shootings so far this year in the USA. Wikipedia says that there have been 48 school-shooting deaths since January 2018. I have had to conduct active-shooter drills in my classroom. There’s no honor in preparing for some crazy person with a gun who wields more power than I do. His rights are firmly protected by the Constitution and the NRA. What about our right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness?
I don’t want to put down the work of our military; they have an important role. But when the focus is so strongly on the heroism of death, why aren’t we honoring the teachers and students who face a lunatic gunman and come out alive? Instead we get Parkland students mocked and threatened for daring to speak out after surviving a school shooting where 17 children were gunned down. They were followed around by badass NRA-provoked warriors in tank-like vehicles. When students and ordinary people are the ones making “the ultimate sacrifice,” who is honoring their deaths? *
Why aren’t we honoring people who bring peace to our communities? The Martin Luther Kings of the future? The activists and leaders who speak out against killing and preventable gun violence? In 1961 President Kennedy founded the U.S. Peace Corps. My ESOL 5 students started a unit about it this week. I was a Peace Corps Volunteer and I served this country. I raised my right hand and swore an oath to the U.S. Constitution, against all enemies, foreign and domestic. More than 235,000 volunteers have served in 141 countries. We’ve never gotten an entire holiday dedicated to our service. What about all the Foreign Service workers and diplomats? The ones who do the actual work of promoting the interests of the United States? I served again as an English Language Fellow helping promote American ideals overseas. Why is peaceful service not being honored?
All the flag waving feels hollow to me. I don’t want to glorify death via military service or any other way. When students and ordinary people are the ones making “the ultimate sacrifice,” who is honoring their deaths? Next Memorial Day, I will honor the peacemakers.
* Hot off the press! Parkland school journalists win Pulitzer Prize!
4 thoughts on “Memorial Day”
Excellent! I was a career naval officer. And that’s what it is for most of us: a well-remunerated, challenging, interesting career. I never got shot at. Sure, doing intelligence operations in airplanes, submarines, cruisers and an aircraft carrier close to the then-Soviet Union had some risks of accidental collision etc. I missed some family time. Those who risk death or mutilation in combat deserve some special recognition. But most professional military folks detest parades and all the rah-rah at ballgames. It’s a cheapening of true patriotism. There’s a saying about scoundrels and patriotism that I’ll look up… Thanks for your post – and thanks for your service!
Samuel Johnson: “Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting post. My country is only one which paid war reparations! Our country is full of war memorials on graveyards! They are well-kept. Here is how they look like:
Although we lost the war, we got gorgeous war machines from Your country. With these fighters the Finnish war pilots gained 447 air victories for 19 losses. Nowadays one of them (the only one in the world) is in this museum:
Aviation Museum of Central Finland
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your war memorials and museums in Finland look very similar to those in the USA. I have no problem with honoring “fallen soldiers,” but I think it’s time to balance out the public recognition of the peace-makers and the peace-keepers around the world.